This island favorite offers a varied, reasonably priced menu for lunch and dinner, and features their extensive sushi bar. In addition to sushi, the peel-and-eat shrimp, lobster rolls and clam chowder are favorites, as are The Oar’s mudslides. The Oar is an island landmark famous for the hundreds of painted oars that hang from the ceiling. The views of New Harbor are unbeatable inside and outside (on the spacious porch). Open daily mid-May to Columbus Day.